Friday, November 15, 2019

Wind-Generator Discussion Extended

The German Bundestag picked up the discussion item this week of distance on wind-generators for energy.  Early in the week, it was leaning toward a goal of 1,000 meters (1 km, or .6 mile). 

For those who aren't aware, wind-generators since the early 1990s have been on this 'turbo-like' goal of placement around Germany.  There's a goal out there.....that they will make up 65-percent of the grid action....by 2030. 

So this funny thing started up twenty years ago, and it's really sharpened up in the past five years...anger and frustration over the placement of wind-generators....too near houses and communities. 

What people say is that there a 'vibration' that exists.  Animals react funny if the wind-generators are too close to houses.  People claim an unhealthy aspect, in reaction to the rotating blades.

True or false?  What you can cite as a fact is that birds are flopping into them....on a daily basis.  You can cite that some field mice are affected.  Beyond that....there's not exactly any university research teams digging in human reaction or to share how vibration is to be measured. 

Current placement of wind-generators?  You can go back to the 1990s and find that the highest priority was just to find elevated areas where wind was sufficient, and they might have been placed within 300 meters of houses.  In the past decade, a lot of community pressure has been put on the approval stage, and it's safe to say you can't get any closer to a kilometer of a housing area....but's not a written law. 

So the CDU Energy Minister (Altmaier) said that it's drafted up and the CDU-CSU-SPD coalition should pass such a law.

But it's a funny thing.....the SPD Environmental Minister (Schulze) stood up and said 'no'.....if you do something like this, then half of the lands that might be considered for placement.....will be forbidden.  So the SPD, along with the Greens, and very likely the Linke Party.....will stand against the law on 1-km placement.

Naturally, you'd stand there and laugh over this discussion.  Community leadership, city councils and mayors.....are the ones with the final say, and they can disapprove any application, and mandate not just one kilometer, but any distance within their city limits. 

But lets go back to the whole goal of 65-percent wind-power by 2030.  It's already mandated that coal and nuke power will disappear by that point, so you absolutely have to have wind-generators continue at a hefty pace (which isn't the case for 2018 or 2019). 

The question is.....are we entering a five-year period where reality approaches, and they can't reach 65-percent....thus having to admit that in public, and retreat from their nuke or coal stance?  Or will they just bluff everyone, and buy non-German nuke or coal power from Poland or France after 2030....at hefty rates? 

No comments: